Small but important correction about the previous post!
above I’ve done one mistake, “which tho cant be found anywhere in Islam and as official symbol actually used since tengri&mazdaistic times by sufis” what would be illogical claim coz Islam dont came after them, but gnostic heresies survived and later infiltrated in Islam as were earlier trying to infiltrate in Christianity!, covert infiltration indeed, altho which in Orthodox Christianity once detected were promptly refuted and removed (eg. when Christianity wanst recognized The Holy Apostles were keeping the purity of Christian Theology while later The Bible along All Dogmas and Canons were standardized by Holy Councils and verified by Emperor), still heresies constantly were popping out and Emperors again and again needed to intervene … this would be mine understanding but not based on apologetic argumentation of OC theologians, simply I am nor educated firmly nor explored deeply theoria but rather has praxis that gave me Clarity so even as halfliterate would easily grasp what is The Truth as Orthodox Christian!, what says big time how I can even less come to fine understanding of Islam and its tenets or heresies unless I dont try like this to explore it through mosaic reasoning!, in a way I am aware by the witnessing of Elder Cleopa that Our Almighty Lord will have indeed Righteous Judgement above all of us as Monotheists but also pagans too So Dont Judge with narrow mind (check the link at the end of the next footnote [1]), altho sadly but some Muslims not aware about us like Christians as fully awaken for The True Nature of Our Almighty Lord some of them indeed in their various examinations label us also as errored altho Monotheists [2] what would be even more ridiculous if they claim utmost obedience to the Prophet Mohamed but not respecting his will to give exclusion for persecution of Christians [3] and my firm belief is that if modern apologetic debates become normal occurrence even themselves will grasp our position as complete especially if we know that we have similar eschatology regards Jesus Christ that we as Orthodox Christians recognize it as Incarnation of Our Almighty Lord that will come again before The Final Judgement just as is seen by Islam too but there its seen as Prophet to whom Archangel Michael will give the keys of this world so He would gather His Umma [4][4] so what this means To Whom Belongs The Umma!?, and why this kind of digression in this post, simply we all need to see apologetic debates among theologians so we would understand eachother positions firmly and like that finding tolerance as neighbors eg. indeed find very informative JayD recently [5][5] what gives me from Christian perspective crush course so would employ correctly the main postulate of Love through Christ so would reach clarity and instead to affraid to tolerate pagans and neopagans that live among us or trying to sell their knowhow on small door through modern media in form of movie or music subconscious programming, especially now when we live under the law of secularism and however however likes can flush its own knowledge however errored it is!, altho that dont means blind love and taking part in their deeds still in same time also dont means our blind judgement but asks always for Dialog till Clarity who is who and why its doing something!, yet in Islam that is bit harder coz Islam per’se above all rest on The Law and then after The Love, while in Christianity The Love is Fulfilment of The Law coz we are weak but through Christ we can heal and cover our incapability to fulfill Our Oath for The Law from The Old Testament, but in same time The Final Judgement will be most harsher for us coz we would not have no excuse why we didnt have understanding and temperance regards whoever sinned or errored even attacked us i.e. we need to be Aware for Our Gift Through Christ thus to Forgive and ask for Peace even when that looks impossible i.e. we are attacked physically when need to find way first to evade evil and then after if cant to defend not from pride but from necessity eg. to survive!
~
if I know something about Islam and its main two branches Shia and Sunni I know that both of them follow Orthodox Islam, but altho modern sufism obviously surfaced through sassanid sufis still didnt survived as heretical muslim vibe in Persia but took refuge in the Ottoman Empire [1] where tho also didnt had have some ultra expansion, yet coz those sufis were educated simply occupied the sultans court and like that influenced the elites maybe to astray, but didnt corrupted the Sunni Islam in the Caliphate!, yet how much such esoteric occult pagan teachings were trying to infiltrate Islam on such elitist level I cant say, simply havent explored Islam thoroughly so would know and claim certainty, (maybe someone can offer some influence diagram) yet it could be seen just by the proposed footnoted info in the previous post that that was indeed case!, the question is who is who among such sufis (i.e. devoted teachers), and its obviously that not all sufis stand firm in Orthodox Islam but even worst misuse the label Sufi what would be as pointed in the 8th footnote in the previous post an label for Sahaba, but as could be see from this next footnote [2] defacto later all even heretic muslims were borrowing or was thrown then such title, thus now we have kind of paradox that even sunni muslims are in need to defend the Sufi title as derived from Sahaba, but how to explain what is not and who is not sufi to the western observer when someone hijacked the term and pretend to claim even separate islamic religious practices known as sufism as correct one!, what I know tho is that dervish sects defacto embraced monism as universalism i.e. perennialism (all religious paths lead to God) what in essence is wrong [2] that has nothing with Islam eg. going in ecstasy through pagan alike meditation under influence of drinks or herbs and/or felling in trance by movements to reach enlightenment!, wrong!, now am I certain about this Yep utmost certain coz as practicing ex-pagan I’ll witness that without Fullness of Faith i.e. Righteousness regards the accepted Monotheistic Oath and Law (that arose from the Clarity > that is reached by Grace > that is gained by Prayers and Merit > due to Purity > reached through Fasting and Virtues) without it people will fell in error, and even more if expect even less if believe that someone can reach correct understanding for The Truth by living in trance (or sinful life) that is wrong by all means!, So modern sufism how wrongly syncretizes various ascetic or theologian tradition incompatible to the Oath and Law in Orthodox Islam is indeed heretic point in contrast to it!
in case someone has will to bring some examination of this logicism of mine, resting on particular info from net, and knowing that sufism CANT be narrowed only to Islam, but as heretical sects has ties even to kabbalism, is indeed kinky to be examined as such, even if we take in account only the modern dervish trends that claim suni affiliation, simply such Sufi Conspiracy cant be examined from point of Islam, but as covert new age teachings that got hidden place in some form of mystic cellar where would stay alive, otherwise risked extermination as some mongol tnegri vibe or persian mazdaistic vibe among the newly converted muslims in middle east and central asia!, an strange occurrence that we cant say whether influenced kabbalists or vice versa eg. when got in contact!, hm knowing that kabbalism is in essence zoroastrian knowhow that jews took with themselves while in babilonian exile thus the logic leans more on the second vice versa assumption!?, but maybe as dispersed they’ve forgotten own wrong mystic knowhow and then later when as sephards came back to the middle east after the expulsion from Spain got awaken again!?, or maybe the earlier manichean gnostic vibe through paulicians and bogomils as dualism passed till patarens and cathars and from them to sephardic jews in Spain and from there again came back to middle east once they were expelled from Spain!?, that maybe proves why occult sufis didnt reach in full swing dualistic cosmology but just ontological dualism [3][3] thus the Moon&Sun symbolism is just wrong dualistic mark then!?, hm those who understand that in such occult traditions symbolism plays huge role in explanation of the secrete teaching would not agree!, yet how I would claim certain dualist tendencies by symbol that per’se shouldnt be mark for all sufi sects!?, how we can say their monism resembles dualism, even if seen as affirmative dualism regards their enlightenment, what still its not at all clear mark for all dervish sufism!?, hm here indeed only eventual intermix with kabbalists can give some notion for such possibility coz kabbalah is already exposed and finally one firm direction of kabbalism!, and as could be seen from the “Ibn Kammūna” link in the next footnote they indeed intertwine on some levels “Just how much Jewish ethics, biblical, rabbinic, and medieval, Ibn Kammuna has included is difficult to determine. Jewish and Islamic ethics have been intertwined all along; by the thirteenth century, some rabbinic ideas had become thoroughly islamized on the one hand, and, on the other, Jewish versions of Sufism were well-established. Jews cited snippets of the Qur’an as apothegms of universal wisdom, rather than as the scripture of a particular faith community. So when Ibn Kammuna says that “The beginning (ra’s , cf. Hebrew reishit ) of wisdom is fear of God,” is he consciously importing the verse from Psalms 111:10? Overall, Ibn Kammuna appears to have formulated an original “Abrahamic” philosophical piety. Both the philosophical foundations underpinnings (concepts of the deity and of humanity) as well as the moral values and spiritual exercises, were carefully crafted so as to be acceptable to all monotheists” [4] (just to add Christian Ethics dont rests on such wisdom [5] but maybe kammunas intentions were towards universalism thus somehow that last part of the last sentence sounds as if he had have intention for infiltration or better said to appeal to Monotheists so would influence them!?), anyway here and there can be found other texts about flirt of sufism and kabbalism as modern medieval occult mysticisms, but that again begs the question how much their enlightenment isnt the same and the one, that later was passed on to the european neopagan hype!?
The Question of Sufi Influence on the Early Kabbalah ~ The Question of Sufi Influence on the Early Kabbalah | tomblock.com
again I’ll need to emphasize Dont Judge coz we can only speculate which modern sufi order embraced what, hm 1. on first level (those above mentioned) esoteric sufis embraced pantheism as monism i.e. everything is one, in a way not just equaling as in dualism two gods, but saying that everything is in God, what would be even more wrong to equal all beings as created an equal to The Omnipotent Creator (to banalize that heresy - as if everything its kind dream of His), aside that 2. on second advanced level, such errored monistic basis further goes in error with various syncretization from various mystical schools, as if indeed we speak about new agers of its own time, and when we will see all the rest traits of that esoteric sufism then as such definitely cross in occultism!, now some say sufism is not necessary pantheistic [6] and that can be explained only if we say which sufism!, thus I’ll need indeed not to bother whether or not that dervish sufism has or not this or that traits but whether could lead them to Salvation, and in my humble opinion that is Role to Our Almighty Lord Jesus Christ to Judge us on The Final Judgement!, lets say they are utmost heretical sinners regards Orthodox Islam, yet if judged as pagans and kept the principle of Love as highest among their virtues thus it will do everything from and by Love without hate or judgement to others, and like that their conscious clear thus as Elder Kleopa states it will reach merit for Salvation even as pagans [7] logically if didnt made haram and blasphemy of Allah as The Father that is known to us as Christians through The Son Jesus Christ … eventually the problem is what practices of theirs can have ultra wrong idolizing dualistic form or which dervish sect has such practices eg. that influenced templars and probably those are just one ismailian hashishin sect!, hm cna someone explain this more neatly!?, is this reasoning correct i.e. that modern Darwish Sufis have nothing to do with those that influenced templars!?, take Ur time!